Society · Governance

DocumentedOverride

Supervised bypass of a failed acceptance gate, cryptographically logged

Definition

Mechanism

The override-with-documentation safety valve at hard seams. Accepts a failed AcceptSpec evaluation plus a textual rationale and scoped override authority; composes_with TimeWarpLog to cryptographically log the override event (forward action + override + rationale + signing identity). Yields a forced Decision that bypasses the failed gate. The override is a first-class, audit-trailed coordination act — every bypass carries non-repudiable evidence of who overrode what and why. Preserves fail-closed discipline by making the bypass explicit, named, signed, and logged rather than silent.

Invariants

  1. Every override event must be signed by an identity holding scoped override authority.
  2. Forward action, override, rationale, and signing identity are all logged to TimeWarpLog — no partial records.
  3. Rationale field must be non-empty: a DocumentedOverride with no documentation is not a DocumentedOverride.

Risks

Failure modes

  1. Override authority is over-scoped — any agent can bypass any gate, defeating the fail-closed discipline.

  2. Compromised signing key enables silent override with valid-looking log entries.

  3. Rationale accepts low-information text ('legitimate business reason') that defeats the audit purpose while technically satisfying non-empty.

Caution

Overrides a failed acceptance gate. The cryptographic log is the only post-hoc accountability; ensure override authority is scoped and auditable before composing.

Relationships

Builds on

Accepts

Infrastructure

AcceptSpec

Non-compensatory acceptance contract; consumer Verify yields Solution or FrameError

Composes with

Infrastructure

TimeWarpLog

Handling relativistic event ordering

Yields

Infrastructure

Decision

Irrevocable selection from a set of options

Nothing in this library builds on this pattern yet.

Reference

Identity

Ref
DocumentedOverride#129b
Sema ID
sema:DocumentedOverride#mh:SHA-256:129bb6b19219e4afc278012f555b298980c4a74000195ae1e6766f2e5d40d940
Ring
1
Tier
2
Updated
2026-11-11
Supersedes
  • sema:DocumentedOverride#mh:SHA-256:17d333bda6bfc9f98ef85e9d09dd8cf84a8d8f13f13fb4e5de767bc4c8e75a54
  • sema:DocumentedOverride#mh:SHA-256:40548ac167ea414f493054543303e74dac28a64510aa55ea8d1807ea52a6a5c6
  • sema:DocumentedOverride#mh:SHA-256:2b7763b4dab9fefa6b60e2b2ffd3849509a9b5af43a4ab3604973d55916f6dc4