Mind · Reasoning
CollaborativeWritingProtocol
Decompose quality-constrained production into substance, structure, generation, evaluation, and refinement — five intended low-coupling dimensions a producer must address
Definition
Mechanism
A protocol for producing textual (or any structured) output that must meet a quality standard. Decomposes the concept of quality-constrained production into five intended low-coupling dimensions via ConceptualDecomposition: substance (what material must the artifact contain), structure (how does it organize), generation (produce freely with evaluation elsewhere), evaluation (does it meet the standard across independent quality dimensions), and refinement (surface quality on a structurally complete artifact). Two parallel mechanisms run together: a structural pipeline (ScopeDiscoverySolver → SequencingCoherenceSolver → UnitConstraintSolver → StructuralVerificationSolver → VoiceRefinementSolver) that separates generation from evaluation, and concurrent ObserverSolvers (RepetitionSolver, ContradictionSolver, IntentSolver, AudienceReceptionSolver) that externalize the silent evaluative thinking a solo writer does with interference. The protocol transfers beyond writing to any domain where something must be produced to a standard (music composition, interface design).
Invariants
- Low-coupling dimensions: the five sub-concepts pass the four-test decomposition (ConceptualDecomposition); an observer checking repetition does not generate, and a generator does not self-censor toward criteria it lacks.
- Concurrent-not-sequential: evaluative observers run alongside generation, producing typed annotations that accumulate; they are not editors.
- Variable-depth: each of the five dimensions can itself recurse via its own sub-solver tree when the stakes warrant it (MarginalValueRule governs depth).
Risks
Failure modes
None stated.
Relationships
Builds on
Composes with
Finding what a concept is made of: locate it, carve it into the dimensions every case it claims needs, test each, search for what is missing, route real cases through it, say how the parts make the whole, and carve again below
Deepen only while expected improvement plus an exploration credit, divided by incremental cost, exceeds a domain threshold
Nothing in this library builds on this pattern yet.